Governance Document

Independent Review Mechanism Charter

The Mechanism provides impartial and timely review of disputed technical determinations, including data findings, classifications, certifications, trigger determinations, suspensions, and de-certifications, consistent with Section 7.3(a) of the Bylaws.

Jurisdiction
Missouri
Effective
September 4, 2026
EIN
42-3762205

C-ECO INSTITUTE

Exhibit C to the Action by Sole Incorporator

A Missouri Nonprofit Public Benefit Corporation

EIN: 42-3762205 | Columbia, Missouri

Effective Date: September 4, 2026

Adopted pursuant to Sections 6.10 and 7.3(g) of the Initial Bylaws

PREAMBLE

This Independent Review Mechanism Charter (the "Charter") is adopted by the Sole Incorporator of C-ECO INSTITUTE (the "Institute"), acting before the initial Board of Directors is constituted, and is to be adopted by the Board of Directors pursuant to Section 7.3(g) of the Institute's Initial Bylaws (the "Bylaws"), which requires the Board to "adopt and maintain an Independent Review Mechanism Charter governing standing, admissibility, filing periods, panel selection, conflicts and recusals, access to records, confidentiality, protection against retaliation, accessibility, use of experts, interim measures, decision deadlines, publication or anonymization of decisions, record retention, and coordination with external accountability mechanisms," and pursuant to Section 6.10, which requires a written charter for the Independent Review Mechanism among the Institute's Institutional Bodies.

This Charter implements Section 7.3 of the Bylaws (Establishment and Independence; Review Roster and Case Panels; Initiation and Admissibility; Authority and Procedure; Interim Protective Measures; Finality and Fiduciary Authority) and Section 7.1 (Separation of Functions). Defined terms not otherwise defined in this Charter have the meanings given to them in the Bylaws. In the event of any conflict between this Charter and the Bylaws, the Bylaws control, consistent with Section 11.3 of the Bylaws.

ARTICLE 1

ESTABLISHMENT, PURPOSE, AND INDEPENDENCE

1.1 Establishment

There is hereby established the Independent Review Mechanism (the "Mechanism") as an Institutional Body of the Institute under Section 1.2(c) of the Bylaws. The Mechanism is the body through which the independent review process described in Sections 3.2 and 7.3 of the Bylaws is conducted.

1.2 Purpose

The Mechanism provides impartial and timely review of disputed technical determinations, including data findings, classifications, certifications, trigger determinations, suspensions, and de-certifications, consistent with Section 7.3(a) of the Bylaws.

1.3 Independence

The Mechanism shall operate independently from the persons and Institutional Bodies responsible for the challenged determination and from the Institute's operational, commercial, fundraising, and applicant-support functions (Bylaws Section 7.3(a)). No individual, committee, or corporate body within or contracted by the Institute may simultaneously serve as the sole operator, certifier, auditor, and appellate decision-maker for the same project, dataset, or classification framework (Bylaws Section 7.1).

ARTICLE 2

REVIEW ROSTER

2.1 Composition

The Board shall appoint a roster of qualified independent reviewers (the "Roster") possessing appropriate scientific, technical, legal, procedural, community, or sectoral expertise, consistent with Bylaws Section 7.3(b). The Roster shall be sufficiently diverse in expertise to permit formation of a qualified case panel for any matter reasonably expected to arise under Article VI or VII of the Bylaws.

2.2 Proposed size and terms

Unless otherwise fixed by Board resolution, the Roster shall consist of not fewer than five (5) members. Each Roster member shall serve a term of two (2) years, renewable, and may be removed by the Board for cause, incapacity, or repeated unavailability. Roster terms should be staggered as reasonably practicable once the Roster exceeds its initial appointment.

2.3 Appointment

The Board shall appoint Roster members upon recommendation of the Scientific and Calibration Council or the Technical Curatorship Chamber, as appropriate to the nominee's area of expertise, or upon direct Board nomination where no such recommendation is practicable at the Institute's current stage of operation.

2.4 Qualification standard

A Roster member must not, at the time of appointment or during service, be an employee of the Institute or a member of the Executive Leadership Council. This standard implements the independence requirement of Bylaws Section 7.3(a).

ARTICLE 3

CONFLICTS AND RECUSALS

3.1 Mandatory recusal

No Roster member may participate in a matter in which that member participated in the original determination under review, has a material conflict of interest, or lacks the independence required by this Charter (Bylaws Section 7.3(b)).

3.2 Disclosure

Each Roster member shall disclose, before accepting assignment to a case panel, any financial, professional, or personal relationship with a party to the matter, in accordance with the Institute's Conflict of Interest Policy and Article VIII of the Bylaws, which treats a consulting agreement, professional-services agreement, or intellectual-property license agreement to which the person is a party as a material financial interest.

3.3 Substitute reviewers

Where a Roster member recuses or is disqualified under this Article, a substitute reviewer with comparable qualifications shall be assigned from the Roster, or, if no qualified Roster member is available without a conflict, the Board may appoint an ad hoc reviewer for that matter alone, subject to the same qualification and disclosure standards as a Roster member. This implements the "substitute reviewers" requirement of Bylaws Section 7.1.

ARTICLE 4

CASE PANELS AND PANEL SELECTION

4.1 Panel size

Each matter shall be determined by an odd-numbered case panel of not fewer than three (3) reviewers drawn from the Roster and selected according to the nature of the dispute (Bylaws Section 7.3(b)).

4.2 Selection process

Panel members shall be selected by the review officer described in Article 6 of this Charter, applying the qualification, independence, and conflicts standards of Articles 2 and 3, and shall be selected to match the scientific, technical, legal, procedural, community, or sectoral expertise relevant to the matter under review.

4.3 Panel decision rule

A case panel shall decide by majority vote of its members. Each final determination shall be supported by written findings and reasons (Bylaws Section 7.3(d)).

ARTICLE 5

STANDING, INITIATION, AND ADMISSIBILITY

5.1 Standing

A review may be initiated by: (a) an affected person or entity; (b) an authorized representative of an affected person or entity; (c) an Institutional Body with responsibility for the matter; or (d) any person submitting a report through the whistleblower and community-access channels described in Bylaws Section 7.5, subject to the confidentiality and anti-abuse safeguards of that Section (Bylaws Section 7.3(c)).

5.2 Filing requirements

A request for review shall be in writing and shall identify: (a) the challenged determination; (b) the grounds for review; and (c) the relief requested (Bylaws Section 7.3(c)).

5.3 Filing period

Unless a governing contract or applicable law fixes a different period, a request for review must be filed within sixty (60) days of the date the challenged determination was issued or, if later, the date the requesting party knew or reasonably should have known of the determination. The review officer may extend this period for good cause shown.

5.4 Admissibility screening

An independent secretariat or designated review officer may determine procedural completeness and admissibility, but shall not decide the merits of the matter (Bylaws Section 7.3(c)).

5.5 Accessibility

Filing shall not require payment of a fee. The Institute shall make the filing procedure and this Charter available in plain, accessible language, and shall accommodate a requesting party's reasonable need for translation or an alternative format, consistent with the Institute's obligation under Bylaws Section 7.5 to enable affected communities, civil-society participants, and independent researchers to submit technical observations and request formal reviews.

ARTICLE 6

AUTHORITY AND PROCEDURE

6.1 Review officer

The Board shall designate a review officer (who may be a Roster member, Institute staff member other than the Executive Director, or outside administrator) to receive filings, screen admissibility under Article 5, and constitute case panels under Article 4. The review officer shall not decide the merits of any matter.

6.2 Panel authority

A case panel may obtain relevant records, receive written submissions, consult independent experts, and conduct hearings or technical conferences where appropriate (Bylaws Section 7.3(d)). Access to Institute records for this purpose is subject to the confidentiality protections of Article 8 of this Charter and any applicable data-governance or third-party confidentiality obligation of the Institute.

6.3 Use of experts

A case panel may retain independent experts where the matter requires expertise beyond that of the panel's own members. An expert retained under this Article is subject to the same disclosure and conflicts standards applicable to a Roster member under Article 3.

6.4 Disposition

A case panel may affirm, modify, reverse, or remand the challenged determination within the authority delegated by the Bylaws and this Charter (Bylaws Section 7.3(d)).

ARTICLE 7

INTERIM PROTECTIVE MEASURES

The filing of a request for review shall not automatically stay a temporary protective measure adopted to preserve systemic reversibility, ecological integrity, data integrity, or public safety (Bylaws Section 7.3(e)). A case panel may maintain, modify, or stay such a measure upon consideration of the risk of irreversible harm, the reliability of the underlying evidence, proportionality, and applicable law. Any protective governance intervention designated as immediate, temporary, and operationally reversible remains subject to the trigger-integrity safeguards of Bylaws Section 7.2, including that it may not be waived, bypassed, or delayed solely for commercial convenience or financial expediency.

ARTICLE 8

DECISIONS: DEADLINES, FINALITY, AND PUBLICATION

8.1 Decision deadline

Unless the review officer extends the period for good cause shown and documents the basis for the extension, a case panel shall issue its written determination within ninety (90) days of the date a request for review is deemed admissible under Article 5.

8.2 Finality

A decision of a case panel constitutes the final technical determination of the Institute, subject only to the Board's authority to act when reasonably necessary to discharge a nondelegable legal or fiduciary duty. Any departure by the Board shall comply with Bylaws Section 3.2 and shall state its legal, procedural, or evidentiary basis in the corporate minutes (Bylaws Section 7.3(f)).

8.3 Publication or anonymization

A case panel's written determination shall be made available consistent with the Institute's public-transparency obligations under Bylaws Section 6.8 (Public Observatory) and Section 7.8, subject to lawful protections for privacy, security, Indigenous data governance, contractual confidentiality, and protected intellectual property. Where publication in full would disclose personal data, confidential business information, or other legally protected information, the determination shall be published in anonymized or redacted form sufficient to preserve the reasoning and outcome while protecting the protected information.

ARTICLE 9

CONFIDENTIALITY AND PROTECTION AGAINST RETALIATION

9.1 Confidentiality

Case panel deliberations, and any record submitted under seal or marked confidential, shall be maintained in confidence by the review officer, panel members, and any expert retained under Article 6, except as necessary to prepare the written determination or as required by applicable law.

9.2 Non-retaliation

The Institute shall maintain confidential, non-retaliatory reporting and review channels consistent with Bylaws Section 7.5. No person shall be subject to retaliation by the Institute, an Institutional Body, or a licensee or operator subject to the Institute's authority, for filing a request for review in good faith or for participating in good faith in a review under this Charter.

ARTICLE 10

RECORD RETENTION, AUDIT TRAIL, AND EXTERNAL COORDINATION

10.1 Audit trail

Every request for review, admissibility determination, panel assignment, interim measure, and final determination shall be logged in the audit trail required by Bylaws Section 7.4, using immutable or tamper-evident technical records and, where a technical correction is required, a supplemental or ledgered entry rather than an undisclosed overwrite.

10.2 Record retention

Records of a review under this Charter shall be retained in accordance with the Institute's document-retention policy adopted under Bylaws Section 8.4, and in no event for a shorter period than the retention period generally applicable to the technical records under Bylaws Section 7.4.

10.3 Coordination with external accountability mechanisms

Where a matter before the Mechanism is also the subject of a governmental, regulatory, or other external accountability proceeding, the review officer shall coordinate scheduling and information-sharing with that external mechanism to the extent consistent with applicable law, confidentiality obligations, and the Institute's tax-exempt purposes, and shall document that coordination in the corporate minutes.

ARTICLE 11

AMENDMENT

This Charter may be amended by the Board of Directors consistent with the Bylaws. No amendment may contradict or materially weaken the functional separation, independence, and conflict-of-interest safeguards required by Bylaws Section 6.10, or the specific protections of Bylaws Section 7.1 through 7.5.

ADOPTION

This Charter was adopted by Jacqueline A. Ennis, acting as Sole Incorporator under RSMo Section 355.111 before the initial Board of Directors was constituted, by the Action of the Sole Incorporator dated September 4, 2026, to which it is attached as an exhibit, and is effective on September 4, 2026. As required by Sections 6.10 and 7.3(g) of the Initial Bylaws, the Board of Directors shall adopt this Charter, with or without amendment, upon taking office; the Charter remains in effect until the Board so acts. The signature below certifies adoption by the Sole Incorporator; adoption by the Board is recorded in its Unanimous Written Consent.

Jacqueline A. Ennis,
Sole Incorporator

Date: September 4, 2026